Procurement Documents

Vendor Evaluation Matrix and RFP Scoring Template (Free)

Score up to five vendors against weighted criteria in your browser or in Excel: a 1-to-5 scale, must-have checks, weighted totals out of 5.00 and a ranking.

3 sheets Microsoft Excel Updated November 15, 2026
Download Template
Vendor Evaluation Matrix and RFP Scoring Template (Free) preview
Vendor Evaluation Matrix: Free Excel Template and Calculator

Preview an example

See the matrix with example scores before you download. The Excel file has the matrix, the instructions and a consensus sheet, ready to fill in.

What's inside

The sections in the document, in order.

  1. How to use the vendor evaluation matrix
  2. How the scoring works
  3. Using it as an RFP scoring template
  4. Vendor evaluation matrix, decision matrix or vendor scorecard?
  5. Frequently asked questions
  6. Related guides and templates

A vendor evaluation matrix scores every vendor against the same weighted criteria, so your team compares proposals on evidence instead of impressions. Try the calculator below with your own criteria and vendors, then download the Excel version to share with your evaluation team.


It uses the method in the RFP scoring and evaluation criteria guide: set the weights before any proposals arrive, score each criterion from 1 to 5, and multiply by the weight. A vendor that fails a Must-have requirement is out, whatever its score.


What's inside this template


  • An Excel matrix for up to 12 criteria and five vendors, with the weighted totals calculated for you
  • A weight check that warns you when the weights don't add up to 100
  • A Must-haves row that marks a vendor Eliminated when it fails a pass-or-fail requirement
  • Weighted scores out of 5.00 and a ranking of the vendors still in the running
  • A consensus sheet for comparing each evaluator's scores before you agree a final score
  • A 1-to-5 scale with a definition for every score, and example weights to adjust

Use the calculator on this page, or download the editable Excel version below.

Vendor evaluation matrix calculator

Edit the criteria and weights, name your vendors, and score each one from 1 (poor) to 5 (exceeds). The totals update as you go. Nothing you enter leaves your browser.

Swipe the table sideways to score each vendor; the criteria stay in view.

Download the Excel version

How to use the vendor evaluation matrix

  1. List your criteria. Use the main areas you’ll judge, such as functional fit, technical and security, implementation and support, vendor strength and references, and cost. Keep the detailed requirements in the RFP itself and roll them up here.
  2. Set the weights before proposals arrive. Agree them with the buying team and make them total 100. The example weights are a starting point only, so the scoring can’t drift toward a favorite later.
  3. Score independently, then agree. Each evaluator scores alone using the 1-to-5 scale. Compare the scores on the consensus sheet and agree one score per criterion, with the evidence behind it.
  4. Check the Must-haves. Enter No for any vendor that misses a Must-have requirement. The matrix marks it Eliminated, whatever its weighted score.
  5. Read the totals, then decide. The weighted score is out of 5.00. A close result is a reason to look harder at references, a proof of concept or cost, not to round in someone’s favor.

How the scoring works

Each score is multiplied by its criterion’s weight and divided by 100, and the results are added. With weights that total 100, a perfect vendor scores 5.00. The weights below are the example split from the RFP process guide, as an example only.

Criterion Weight Score (1 to 5) Weighted score
Functional fit 35 4 1.40
Technical and security 20 3 0.60
Implementation and support 15 4 0.60
Vendor strength and references 10 5 0.50
Cost 20 3 0.60
Total 100 3.70

The 1-to-5 scale

  • 5 Exceeds: meets every Must-have and most Nice-to-haves, shown in a demonstration or proof of concept, with a matching reference customer.
  • 4 Strong: meets every Must-have and some Nice-to-haves, with clear evidence.
  • 3 Adequate: meets most Must-haves; gaps have a credible workaround or a dated roadmap commitment.
  • 2 Weak: misses one or more Must-haves, or the answer is vague.
  • 1 Poor: does not meet the requirement, or no answer.

Using it as an RFP scoring template

To score RFP responses, enter the evaluation criteria and weights your RFP published, in the same order, so every evaluator scores against what vendors were told. Each evaluator scores alone first, then the team agrees one score per criterion on the Consensus sheet. Vendors that miss a Must-have are marked Eliminated before any weighted total counts. The RFP scoring matrix guide explains how to choose the criteria and set the weights before the RFP goes out.

Vendor evaluation matrix, decision matrix or vendor scorecard?

A decision matrix is the general method: options in columns, weighted criteria in rows, a score in each cell. A vendor evaluation matrix is a decision matrix for choosing a supplier, usually once the proposals from an RFP are in.

A vendor scorecard does a different job: it rates a supplier you already use against its contract, in regular reviews after signing. For that, use the vendor scorecard template.

Frequently asked questions

What is a vendor evaluation matrix?

It’s a table that scores each vendor against the same criteria, with a weight for each criterion, so you can compare proposals on one scale. Each score is multiplied by its weight and the results are added, giving every vendor a weighted total. It’s usually built before the RFP is issued and filled in once the proposals arrive.

How do you create a weighted scoring matrix?

List the criteria you’ll judge, give each a weight so the weights total 100, and define what each score from 1 to 5 means. Score each vendor on each criterion, multiply each score by its weight, divide by 100 and add the results. Set the weights before you see any proposals.

What criteria should a vendor evaluation matrix include?

Most software purchases cover functional fit, technical fit and security, implementation and support, vendor strength and references, and cost over the full term. Weight them by what matters most for this purchase, and keep the detailed requirements in the RFP rather than the matrix.

How do you handle must-have requirements in a scoring matrix?

Treat them as pass or fail before you look at the scores. A vendor that can’t meet a Must-have is out, however well it scores elsewhere. This template has a Must-haves row that marks such a vendor Eliminated.

Is a vendor evaluation matrix the same as a vendor scorecard?

No. A vendor evaluation matrix compares vendors before you choose one. A vendor scorecard rates a supplier you already use against its contract, usually in regular reviews after signing.

Related guides and templates

Download Template

More procurement documents templates